CLEARANCE SALE : HUGE SAVINGS 🏷️

WHILE SUPPLIES LAST ⏳

UP TO 60% OFF SELECTED GEAR 🔻

Will a Cargo Box Fit on an Overland Platform Rack? Our Thule Force 3 XXL Test

Diagram of a Thule Force 3 XXL cargo box on a Sherpa Crestone platform rack, before and after removing crossbars

Ryan ryan@modularacks.com |

Short answer: yes, you can mount a cargo box on an overland platform rack, but on most of them you have to take a few crossbars out first. Cargo boxes don't have flat bottoms. With every bar in place, the low parts of the box base sit on the bars, the box gets propped up, and the clamps can't grab anything. Pull the bars under those low sections, line up two bars with the clamps, and the box drops down and locks in properly.

We got this question from a customer with a 5th gen Toyota 4Runner, a Sherpa Crestone rack and a Thule Force 3 XXL. So we put a tape measure on a Force 3 XXL here in the shop and worked it through. The numbers are below, and the same idea applies to most overland-style platform racks.

Why won't my cargo box clamp to my overland rack?

Look at the underside of almost any roof box and you'll see it isn't flat. There are lower sections at the front, middle and rear, with raised channels in between. The mounting clamps sit up in those channels. The box was designed to sit on two crossbars, with the low sections hanging down in the open space between and around them.

A full overland or platform rack puts a crossbar every foot or so along the roof. Now the low sections land right on top of the bars. The box sits too high, and the clamp jaws hang in the air above the bars they're supposed to wrap around. You can crank the knobs all you want. They have nothing to grab.

I'm not aware of any cargo box with a base flat enough to sit on a full platform rack with every bar in place, so plan on removing a few bars with whichever box you choose.

Which overland racks does this apply to?

This applies to any platform where the crossbars or slats run side to side across the roof. That covers most of the big overland names, including the Sherpa Crestone, Prinsu, Front Runner Slimline II, Thule Caprock and the Leitner Designs ACS Roof. The number of bars and how far apart they sit changes from rack to rack, so the bars you remove will be different on each one.

Rhino-Rack Pioneer platforms are a different story. Their channels run front to back instead of side to side, so a cargo box mounts to them in a different way. We cover slat direction in our Bronco Sport rack comparison.

Our test: Thule Force 3 XXL on a 5th gen 4Runner with a Sherpa Crestone

White 5th gen Toyota 4Runner with a Sherpa Crestone overland platform rack and A-pillar lights
Our customer's 5th gen 4Runner with its Sherpa Crestone overland rack.

Thule lists the Force 3 XXL at 91.4" long. That number scared us at first, because the Sherpa Crestone for the 2010-2024 4Runner is only 95" long. It looked like the box would cover the whole rack, including the wind fairing and the front and rear crossbars.

Then we measured the box itself. The nose and tail curve up, so the part of the base that actually sits down in the rack is just under 84" long. The nose and tail ride over the fairing and the end bars instead of sitting on them.

We also measured how far the low sections drop below the surface that sits on the crossbar. It came out to about 1 1/4" on one side and about 1 1/2" on the other. We use 1 1/2" to be safe.

Side-view diagram of a Thule Force 3 XXL cargo box on a Sherpa Crestone platform rack on a 5th gen Toyota 4Runner. With every crossbar in, the box's low sections rest on the bars and the clamps can't grab. With the bars under the low sections removed, the box drops down, the clamps wrap two crossbars, and the fairing and end bars stay in place.

Measurement Number Where it comes from
Force 3 XXL overall length 91.4" Thule spec
Force 3 XXL base length (the part that sits in the rack) Just under 84" Measured in our shop
How far the low sections drop below the crossbar About 1 1/4" to 1 1/2" Measured in our shop
Spacing between the two clamp bars 21 7/8" to 36 5/8" Thule spec
Sherpa Crestone (5th gen 4Runner) size 95" x 47 1/2" x 2 1/2" tall, 9 crossbars Sherpa spec
Prinsu full rack (5th gen 4Runner) size 92" long, adds about 1 3/4" of height Prinsu spec

On the Crestone, the rack sits about 2 1/2" tall at the centre of the roof. Take away the 1 1/2" drop and you have roughly an inch between the box and the roof. That works.

The Prinsu is a lower rack, at about 1 3/4" tall. With the same 1 1/2" drop, that leaves roughly a quarter inch. That's tight enough that you need to measure your own truck before you commit.

Which crossbars do I remove?

  1. Find the low sections on your box. Flip the box over or look underneath. Lay a straightedge across one of the clamp channels and measure down to the bottom of the low section beside it. That's your drop.
  2. Measure your rack. Measure from the top of a crossbar down to the roof at the centre of the roof, where it sits highest. That number needs to be bigger than your drop, ideally by half an inch or more.
  3. Check the length. Measure from the back edge of the front crossbar, just behind the fairing, to the front edge of the rear crossbar. The base of your box needs to fit in that space. For the Force 3 XXL, that means more than 84".
  4. Remove the bars under the low sections. Leave the fairing and the front and rear crossbars in place. They help hold the rack together.
  5. Line up two bars with the clamps. Move two crossbars so they sit in the raised channels where the clamps are. On the Force 3, Thule wants those two bars 21 7/8" to 36 5/8" apart.
  6. Set the box down and clamp it. The low sections should drop down between the bars, and the clamp jaws should wrap fully under the two bars you kept.

What if it doesn't fit?

Go one size down. If the base of the XXL won't fit between your end bars, the Force 3 XL is 84.8" overall, 6.6" shorter than the XXL. That gives you more room to work with. Not sure which Force box suits you? Our Force 3 vs Force XT comparison goes through the differences.

Raise the box instead of removing bars. Front Runner sells a Quick-Release Cargo Box Bracket Kit that adds mounting points above their Slimline II slats. The trade-off is a taller setup.

A note on T-track adapters. Thule's T-Track Adapter bolts a PowerClick box straight into the T-slot of a crossbar instead of clamping around it. It fits crossbars with a 20 mm T-track, so check your rack's slot first. It changes how the box attaches, not where the box sits, so you still need to clear the bars under the low sections.

Frequently asked questions

Do any cargo boxes have flat bottoms?

Not that I'm aware of. Boxes are shaped underneath to sit on two crossbars, with the low sections hanging between and around them. That's why a full platform needs a few bars removed.

Will removing crossbars weaken my rack?

Keep the fairing and the front and rear crossbars in place. On racks like the Crestone and Prinsu, those end pieces help hold the side rails together. If you're unsure, check your rack maker's instructions for the minimum number of bars.

Will the box hit my rear hatch?

Not if the box stays within the footprint of the rack. That's the case in our 4Runner and Crestone example. Hatch clearance only becomes a concern when the box hangs past the back of the roof.

Does this work on a Rhino-Rack Pioneer platform?

Not the same way. Pioneer channels run front to back, so the box mounts differently. Contact us with your setup and we'll walk you through it.

Have a different vehicle, rack or box? Send us your setup and we'll tell you what fits before you buy.

Leave a comment

Please note: comments must be approved before they are published.